Don’t Use the CAPE Ratio

Lots of commentary lately on the CAPE ratio (here are recent articles by Arnott, Swedroe, GMO, and Miller).

I’ve written a book, a white paper, and countless blogs on the topic of the CAPE ratio so I don’t feel the need to rehash a lot of that here as there is plenty in the blog archives.  (But it is working great so far in 2016).

One of the best researchers that has a handle on valuation and using the CAPE ratio is Norbert Kremling at Star Capital.  I sent out this PPT of his to The Idea Farm list a few weeks ago and thought I would share this chart below.

It demonstrates how buying expensive assets, as measured using all sorts of valuation indicators including the CAPE ratio, results in bigger losses in the future.  I’ve always said valuation is a blunt tool. So I often say, fine don’t use the CAPE ratio as most of the value indicators should be in agreement.

And most are right now – and they say the same thing.

US stocks expensive.

Foreign cheaper.

Emerging cheaper-er.  (See RA chart at end).

And the cheapest countries are some of the cheapest they have ever been.

 

Star Capital chart of average and maximum 15-year drawdowns by starting valuation quintile, deeper from high valuations

 

Research Affiliates chart of emerging market CAPE as a ratio of U.S. CAPE, 1997 to 2016, back near the low end of its range
Late-1990s_FIGURE-3_INLINE

Ready to Start Investing with Confidence?

Join thousands of investors who choose evidence over emotion.

Cambria Investment Management, L.P.
3300 Highland Avenue
Manhattan Beach, CA 90266

Scroll to Top

Download four of Meb’s books for free by filling out the form below.

You are now leaving cambriainvestments.com and entering cambriafunds.com. 

The Cambria ETFs are distributed by ALPS Distributors Inc., 1290 Broadway, Suite 1000, Denver, CO 80203, which is not affiliated with Cambria Investment Management, LP, the Investment Adviser for the Fund.